The Case For Israel

I am by no means an unquestioning supporter of Israel. And I am convinced that the focus on the “Israel Lobby” is a good thing for both America and for Israel. But there is no question in my mind that Israel deserves American support and that our alliance should remain strong and steadfast.

The case for Israel is not moral, and it is certainly not biblical. As rationales for the existence of a state, neither argument is convincing.

The Jews are not “owed” anything for the years of pogroms and the Holocaust unless everyone who has ever suffered is owed; nor does the reasoning that the Jews have suffered more than others ring true. The Jews have suffered, but so have millions of others individually and collectively. Suffering, however prolonged or organized, does not warrant special privileges for the sufferer.

As for the bible, I think I speak for every rational human being when I say that it’s existence should be irrelevant in modern geopolitics. It is not, of course. But I am assuming that readers of this post are rational.

No. The case for Israel is political. It is not just that they are a democracy (though this is, obviously, vitally important), it is that they have a flourishing institution that is the essential complement to liberal democracy: a free press.

And this, and this alone, is the true, best reason to support Israel.

There has been a lot of talk lately in neocon circles about a league of democracies. This is a good idea, as far as it goes. But the problem is that all democracies are not constructed equally. Even Israel clings to the idea of itself as a Jewish state, and hence it is not truly democratic. What should be the cornerstone of a league of democracies is a measurement of the freedom of a state’s press.

If, as in Israel, the press is free to openly and repeatedly question the deepest held convictions of the state – its laws, its history, its purpose, its government – than that state deserves to truly belong to a league of democracies.

Without this freedom, even the ballot is compromised. A free press is the absolute (forgive me) sine qua non for any country that wants to truly be a free, liberal democracy.

Advertisements

7 Responses to The Case For Israel

  1. Michael says:

    Good post, inciteful points. I wouldn’t undersell the concept of democracy and Israel as an ally. Your points about suffering are spot on, I often think similarly when I hear about reparations for the sufferings of slavery. Show me a people that hasn’t suffered somehwere in their history. Lastly, on a personal note, the bible’s teachings on Israel are important at that level-the personal. For many, that is the impetus behind their support for Israel coupled with many of the reason you mentiond and they vote it. It shoudl not however be an official policy of the nation based on the biblical teachings.

  2. Sallust says:

    How is being a Jewish state make it not a democracy? Any more than being a British state makes the United Kingdom not a democracy? Than being ‘American’ makes the U.S. not a democracy?

    I’m afraid this argument is patently false because every democracy is made up of some group of people and it can be characterized by that group.

  3. nahnopenotquite says:

    An Israeli state is democratic, like pluralist America and Britain. A Jewish state is only for Jews, and omits the necessary equality for all citizens under the Israeli state banner. The difference is between the words Israeli and Jewish.

  4. bennie says:

    I disagree – although a ‘free press’ is a good thing, I don’t think it should be the only ‘qualifier’ for being included in the democracy club. To me, the policies of a ‘democracy’ towards it’s minorities, should be the gauge of how democratic they really are – by this standard, Israel fails miserably.

  5. bennie says:

    I forgot to mention that I read the Israeli press 2-3 times per week, and in my opinion, it is far freer than the American press is.

  6. Omar says:

    Israel kill Palestinian people. Israel does against Palestinian people as Nazi-fascim did against Jews.

  7. nathan says:

    no, omar. not even close. take your israel-bashing somewhere else.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: